Rose Bowl

Hello!

You may have found this website through a Google search after seeing the Military Working Dog float in the Rose Bowl Parade on January 1st. I’d love to welcome you to the page and I certainly hope you enjoy it, but to be really clear up front, I also need to point out that DFDK9 (Dogs for Defense K-9) is not at all affiliated with the Rose Bowl Parade float!

I did not see the parade, but from what I gather, the logo at the front of the float said “Dogs for Defense.” The logo in question actually says “Dogs for Defense Save Lives” and it is the logo for the Military Working Dog Teams National Monument, which inspired the float. That organization’s website is located at JBMF.us. The actual float was put together by Dick Van Patten’s Natural Balance Dog Food, which, along with PetCo stores and Maddie’s Fund, is a corporate sponsor of the National Monument.

Of course, I would love it if you bookmarked this website or liked us on Facebook, but I don’t want you to think that DFDK9 was represented in this year’s Rose Bowl Parade. Please do take the time to check out the great organization that was, the Military Working Dog Teams National Monument, and if you have some money to spare, please contribute to their great cause!

So, you might wonder, what is this “Dogs for Defense K-9″ about, then? Well, we are a very small group of dog owners and handlers located currently at Fort Drum in upstate New York. We are all either military or military family members with an interest in dogs and working dog history.

We do a number of different displays and talks on dog-related topics, which include the history of military working dogs, working dogs in general, therapy dogs, and dog safety. Our members are available to speak to school classes, educators, civic organizations, and really anyone who’ll invite us and wants to learn more about dogs. We also take our display to living history events / reenactments for the public to see and touch artifacts, ask questions, and see our demonstrations. Here’s an example of our living history display, from last year’s Soldiers Through the Ages at Old Fort Niagara. And here are some of the materials we use to teach dog safety to young children that you can download and print.

I hope you enjoy this page, but please send your support and/or donations to the fine people at the Military Working Dog National Monument, as it was their float and publicity that brought you here!

Thank you!
Chris

Also, check out this great video about the Rose Bowl Parade float. It has some background about the float and the organizations that brought it to you in the parade today!

http://landing.newsinc.com/shared/video.html?freewheel=10557&sitesection=ktla&VID=24111837

Happy Birthday


HAPPY 11th BIRTHDAY, RONJA!

Beginner’s Guide to Dog Packing

Fall is hiking and running season around the country, so I thought I would share my beginner’s guide to backpacking with dogs. I originally wrote this about two years ago as a magazine submission but it was never printed. I figure it’s safe to say that they’re probably not going to print it anytime soon. (However, if you know of a magazine that would like to use any of the materials on my page, please feel free to contact me for permission and terms.)

Backpacking with Dogs – a Beginner’s Guide

Throughout history, dogs have served in a huge variety of rules, from their early days as hunting partners and camp guardians, to more recent work as guides for the blind or detectors of explosive devices, to the many competitive venues dogs and their owners now enjoy, such as agility or dog sledding. One function, however, has been less covered by historians and dog enthusiasts – that of the dog as a beast of burden, the pack dog.

Images of dogs carrying pack baskets appear in medieval European manuscripts, where they’re sadly few and far between, and in the drawings and descriptions of Native American life written by European explorers. While dogs pulling sleds and carts are commonly referenced in both drawing and literature, dogs carrying packs or baskets are more obscure and less commonly seen. Nevertheless, dog packing (backpacking with dogs) has recently made a resurgence among outdoor enthusiasts and dog trainers.

Today’s dog packing falls into one of two categories – casual and serious.

Casual dog packing, the more common type, usually requires the dog to only carry small amounts of weight, maybe a few bottles of water, some poop bags, and his owner’s cell phone and keys. Maybe something a little more, to include treats, a First Aid kit, and possibly some other supplies. Casual packing is frequently used by many dog trainers to help an energetic or unruly dog feel like he “has a job” and to work off that extra bit of energy by adding a weighted pack on normal daily walks. But most commonly, casual packing is something people enjoy doing on their weekends off with their dogs. The average casual hiker goes for day hikes of ten miles or less.

Serious dog packing, the more uncommon type, requires the dog to carry supplies for an extended hike in his pack – food and water for a number of days, collapsible bowls, First Aid equipment, maybe a blanket on which to sleep at night, and so on. A serious dog packer would be someone who spends extended weekends or even weeks on the trail with their dog, racking up the miles as they go. Some folks even hike the entire Appalachian trail – like Rachel over at Solophile who did the entire trip with her dog Micah.

Serious packing is also considered a dog sport, which is primarily engaged in by Siberian Husky and Greater Swiss Mountain Dog owners who can also earn Working Pack Dog titles by participating in hikes for record and with a minimum weight requirement. (The pack dog titles offered by the Greater Swiss Mountain Dog Club is open to any breed of dog, however.)

Whether you’re hoping to pack casually or seriously, all dog packing starts off with two things: the right equipment and the right training.

Let’s talk about equipment.

Anyone who’s ever gotten serious about hiking has probably experienced what happens when their pack doesn’t fit quite right: packs that are too large, shoulder straps that just don’t sit right, or equipment that’s not holding up to the weight carried. Finding the right pack, especially for serious or extended hikes, is an important consideration for the human hiker, and it’s equally important for the hiking dog. Just like human packs, not all dog packs are created equal – there are vast differences in fit, features, and quality.

So what makes a good hiking pack for a dog, then?

Just as with human packs, you should consider the construction and materials, fit, and features when it comes to equipping your four-legged hiking buddy. A good dog pack will be made from quality materials, have padding in the places that come into contact with your dog, and will be designed to fit the dog’s anatomy well. A pack that has a Y-front harness, which looks similar to a Western horse’s breast collar in style, provides the most stability and allows for free movement. This type of harness also helps keep the pack steady, even if the load is not perfectly balanced. A good pack will also be designed in such a way that allows the dog’s shoulder and front legs to support the majority of the pack’s weight. This is important because dogs, unlike horses, have flexible spines, and putting weight onto the center of the dog’s back causes discomfort or even injury, especially if you hike with a lot of weight or for extended trips.

Aside from finding a well-fitted and well-designed pack, conditioning is the most important thing to consider before you head out on your first trip. If you’ve hiked any longer distance – maybe in your Army days – you might know just how uncomfortable carrying too much weight is, especially when you are carrying too much for too far when you’re not quite ready. You wouldn’t just wake up one morning and say, “I’m going to run a marathon today!” unless you’re already a runner and have been training for it. And you probably shouldn’t get off the couch on Saturday morning and decide you’re going to don a 60lbs pack and hike up Whiteface Mountain just because the fancy strikes you, unless you’re prepared and conditioned for the trip. Your dog is no different. You can’t just put 20lbs of weight onto a dog who’s never carried that much and expect him to go on a ten mile hike.

The Greater Swiss Mountain Dog Club recommends that dogs should start out carrying no more than 5% of their body weight when they first start training to become pack dogs, which includes the weight of the pack itself. From there, you can work your way up by gradually increasing both the weight inside the backpack and the distance you’re hiking. A conditioned dog can easily carry 30% of his body weight on an extended hike, and most dogs can easily carry more than that if you consider items that are used up along the way, such as food and water, in your starting pack weight.

The pack itself isn’t the only thing to consider, of course – there’s also the things you might want to pack. That’s something that is going to vary a lot depending on the length and distance of your hike, whether you’re going to be camping out overnight, or whether you are going to hike an extended period with stops to replenish supplies.

On any hike, even a simple day hike, water is both the most important and the heaviest thing that both you and your dog will carry. Platypus bottles are great for dog packs because their non-rigid design is easily packed and can be rolled up once the bottle is empty to save on space. Many newer generation dog packs, such as the RuffWear Singletrack, now come already equipped with Platypus bottles. Speaking of water bottles – if your dog doesn’t know how to drink from a bottle opening (and not all dogs do), a collapsible bowl should also be on your packing list. These can be had in many different styles and colors and most are under $20. I like and use the Sea to Summit X-bowl, myself.

On any longer hike, dog food is also a consideration, and may add significant weight to your packing list. For a day hike, on the other hand, that certainly isn’t a necessity unless you will be missing your dog’s regular meal time. Many people recommend you bring along some snacks for your dog as well, but I’ve never packed any dog treats on hikes. (I just tend to share whatever it is I’m eating when we’re out on hikes.)

Another thing you may want to consider packing is a first aid kit for your dog.

In our years of hiking, we’ve been lucky in that we haven’t had any major injuries on the trail, but we’ve had our share of sore and damaged paw pads. Sometimes, these were due to sharp rocks – which can be unavoidable on some trails – and in one case, the cut was due to another hiker’s ignorance, having broken glass and left the shards. Luckily, treating a cut paw pad is relatively simple and easy if you’re prepared: clean it out, add antibacterial ointment (such as Neosporin or Bacitracin) and then wrap it securely. A good way to wrap a pad is by using a gauze pad on the cut and wrapping it with Vetrap or something similar, such as camo wrap if you happen to have any. I’m particularly a fan of the camo wrap because it tends to be thicker and more heavy duty than the Vetrap. Of course, it’s also more expensive. If you own dog boots, carrying them is a great idea – if for no other reason than to throw them on after an injury to allow your dog to hike back under his own power.

Speaking of first aid – if you’re hiking in an unfamiliar area, it helps to keep emergency contact numbers for nearby veterinary clinics on hand, just in case. Also, make sure your dog is wearing a tag that has a valid phone number for you, a relative, or a friend that can be contacted in case your dog gets lost.

In addition to all that, another important consideration for most dog packers are good trail manners.

The majority of us, unfortunately, will spend most of our hiking time on public trails, such as trails on National Park property. Some of those trails may see very little use and we may not encounter any other hikers while we’re out there. Some of those trails may also be very busy and we may encounter other hikers with and without dogs, bicyclists, horseback riders, even folks hiking with pack goats, which makes good trail manners an absolute requirement.

Unfortunately, many trails and National Parks are now off-limits to four-legged hikers due to complaints and concerns over dogs being allowed to run loose, chasing wildlife, frightening people, and generally being a nuisance. Sadly, there’s little we can do other than conform to the rules and try to leave a good impression so we’re not the cause of dogs getting banned from the trails on which they are currently allowed.

Being “courteous” on the trail means different things to different people – let’s just go over some general “trail rules” that help keep dog packers on friendly terms with other hikers:

  • Keep your dog leashed unless the area specifically allows unleashed dogs. Having a leash on your dog helps prevent a couple of behaviors that get dog hikers banned, such as chasing wildlife and harassing other hikers. This is especially important if your dog doesn’t react to the call “COME!” in every situation – including when he’s halfway down the hill chasing a rabbit.
  • Don’t leave your dog’s poop in the middle of the trail. Sure, it’s nature and poop is bio-degradable, but nobody wants to step in it. Either pick it up and pack it out, or move it a reasonable distance off the trail and cover it up.
  • Don’t let your dog act aggressively toward other hikers, bikers, horseback riders, or other trail users. This means, no barking, lunging or growling at passers-by, even if it’s a horse, a bicycle, or another dog.
  • Bear in mind that some people are genuinely frightened of dogs and may not appreciate your dog approaching them on leash and especially not off-leash. When approaching or passing other people, it’s always best to have your dog next to you and on whichever side will position you between the dog and other trail users you are passing.

A couple of other things worth mentioning are collars and leashes.

If you’re out hiking, your dog should wear a well-fitted flat collar with his ID tags securely attached to it – even if you are using a harness, head halter, or training collar to actually attach the leash to. Your dog’s ID should have a phone number for yourself that is current and can be reached even when you’re not home, such as your cell phone, or your veterinary clinic’s number. You can also get an ID tube, which unscrews to hold a piece of paper on which you can write a current contact number – like a local hotel where you’re staying during your trip – or a number for a friend or family member who can be reached in an emergency.

Leashes come in many different styles and materials, and for hiking, I’ve found that leashes made from climbing rope or similar material work great because they are comfortable in your hand and can, if needed, be tied to your pack or belt so you have your hands free. I like to cut the hand loop off my hiking leads – or make them myself from climbing rope so they have no hand loops to begin with. If your dog likes to chase wildlife, it’s recommended that you use a thicker lead so that you don’t suffer “rope burn” on your hands if your dog decides to suddenly take off on you. Thin, light leashes are great – but having nearly severed a finger with parachute cord, I’d rather use a rope lead these days!

They also make “hands-free” leashes that attach to a belt. Those are fantastic for running but I don’t like them as much for hiking as many of them are only about 4ft and when you’re on a narrow trail, that can be impractical. Extendable leashes (“Flexi Leads”) are generally a bad choice because they’re uncomfortable to hold and can easily snap if a dog “hits the end” when taking off after a squirrel or rabbit. (Actually, I don’t really like extendable leashes for anything. A flat long line is much nicer and doesn’t snap if the dog suddenly sprints forward. Plus, no fiddling with buttons to lock the mechanism and all that jazz.)

A Note on Camping With Dogs

One note at the end – if you plan to camp out with your dog or dogs, some special consideration has to be given to spending the night in a tent, too. Not all dogs understand the concept of a tent, and some are genuinely confused by the feel and sound of your tent bottom or the tarp underneath your tent. Some try to walk out of the mesh screen while it’s closed. (My dog is among those – she believes mesh doesn’t exist.) It’s always a good idea to try out the “tent experience” in your own back yard before taking it to the trail.

A simple flat sheet will prevent a lot of wear and tear from a dog’s nails, too, and help keep your tent floor intact longer, especially on those thin ultralight tents that are so popular with many backpackers. (We have the Eureka! Solitaire, for example.) Sure, it’s an extra thing to pack, but light enough not to make a huge difference and worth its weight in gold, compared to having to repair (or replace) your tent!

Dog Packing Resources

Posted in posts. 1 Comment »

Caught!

Look whom I’ve caught snuggled up with one of the cats!

A Different Tool

I have long held the belief that just about every dog training collar and training device on the market has a legitimate use in the right situation, with the right dog, and in the hands of a competent trainer.

What do I mean by that? Well … A prong collar in the hands of an experienced Schutzhund trainer, for example, is a tool that builds drive and is able to fine-tune corrections with minimal pressure and discomfort to the dog. A head halter in the hands of John Public who just bought it at the pet store and has never been shown its correct use can easily injure a dog that is forging ahead by snapping its neck around sideways. The difference is that mot people perceive the prong collar as cruel, largely because of how it looks, and the head halter as gentle.

I am, however, eating my words today because I’ve found one device where I cannot think of a single legitimate use, a single correct situation in which one might use it, or any dog issue that this device might be used on: I give you the Instant Trainer Leash.

In the video clip, TV spokeswoman Taylor Baldwin introduces us to a couple of people who don’t have any control of their dogs, and then shows us the fantastic solution the commercial is selling – the Instant Trainer leash. The leash is touted as “the gentle way to transform” the dog from being a pulling beast into a dog that walks nicely. Awesome, right? Who wouldn’t want a quick fix to nice leash walking!

It this, supposedly, by using “gentle but firm resistance” to discourage the dog from pulling, making this solution better, the video says, than “choke collars, which can gag and hurt” (the collar shown is not a choke collar), or “complicated harnesses” (the one shown is a simple H harness) that encourage dogs to pull. The fact that harnesses with the leash clip on the dog’s back encourage pulling by enabling dogs to really put their weight into it is just about the only truth I’ve found in this commercial.

Well, that and the fact that the Instant Trainer leash “works with every collar.” Of course it works with every collar – it’s a basic flat nylon lead with a standard bolt-snap at the end. It’ll clip to anything that has a D-ring, really. The only thing that makes it different from any other leash is the fact that it happens to have an extra ring sewn about halfway up the leash. What makes this ring special is that it’s designed to sit approximately at a dog’s kidneys, and according to the commercial, you’re supposed to clip the leash to the collar, then “just run it down the back, under the hips, and through the loop.”

Obvious anatomical errors aside (you’re running it under the abdomen, not under the hips), you’re basically creating a noose around the dog’s stomach. That’s what provides that “gentle pressure” when the dog pulls. Hum. “Gentle pressure,” is it?

Since the device isn’t equipped with a stopper that would prevent the loop from tightening more than a specific amount, it stands to reason that this product functions exactly like a noose – it’ll continue to tighten as long as the dog pulls and as long as the owner is holding the other end. If a dog were to suddenly bolt forward or freak out at the contraption around his stomach, and the owner is dumb enough to keep hanging on to the other end of the lead, the noose would continue to tighten and put pressure on the dog’s stomach. That’s not any healthier than the painful choke collars the commercial is warning us against. If anything, a dog’s abdomen is more sensitive than much of its neck.

But they’ve also managed to kill two birds with one stone by putting pressure not just on the dog’s tummy but also on the dog’s neck. Just look at how the leash fits in the video and you’ll see it’s pulling back on the collar in addition to being tight around the stomach. I’m sure that makes walks so very enjoyable for the dog.

Aside from the obvious question of, “who would by this idiotic contraption”, the other question that comes up is, “what kind of professional trainer or veterinarian would endorse this idiotic contraption?” I looked up both the names mentioned in the video and found that the professional trainer is actually a pet sitter, owner of a Florida pet sitting service, but the veterinarian is a legitimate veterinarian, also in Florida. I can only say that if this were my vet, I would be looking for another clinic to take my dog to. I’m not entirely sure I’d trust her judgment after seeing her endorse such a ridiculous device.

Have you seen anyone use this device?
What do you think?

Disposable

Sadly, we have become a society where everything has become throw-away, from the fast food wrappers and the fifteen miles of packaging for most items (particularly electronics) to our pets. We want instant gratification, but as soon as something becomes inconvenient, hard to deal with, or – worse yet! – time consuming, we just throw it away and try again later. And society as a whole seems to look at this as acceptable behavior.

You just have to look at your local Craig’s List pet ads to see some of those examples of being a throw-away culture. While there are certainly some valid reasons to rehome a pet, I would wager a guess that about 90% of ads on Craig’s List offering to give away or sell pets don’t fall into that category of valid reasons, but rather under the header of “it’s just easier.” Getting a job in a different state? Dump your pets and get new ones once you’re done moving. After all, that’s much easier than moving with a pet. Have two pets that get along? Dump one and keep the other, because that’s much easier for you than having to figure out how to restore harmony in the home or how to rotate and separate the pets. I particularly see this latter one with people who have both a cat and a dog and just can’t be bothered to give the cat a safe place to go.

Here are some from my local Craig’s List.

I have a light orange kitten who is around 7 months old, we havent had him very long. He is a sweety, he likes to cuddle and purrs alot. Spunky is good with other cats and dogs. I also have an orange and white kitten who is about 5 months old. Robin is a little cutie with big eyes who likes to cuddle and purr. He is good with other cats and dogs. The reason we need to rehome the kittens is cause my husband’s dog keeps trying to eat them. They are free to a good home and it doesnt matter if they go together or seperate.

Here’s a real winner. No money or time to get shots for eight puppies, but enough time to breed their dogs and sell the pups for $100 a piece. I wonder what their justification for $100 per puppy is? Certainly not the excellent vet care they’ve been receiving.

very cute puppies for sale, price $100, dewormed, no shots just didnt have the money or time for eight puppies

Here’s someone who’s moving and “can’t take” the dog. (Can someone tell me where all these states or towns are that don’t allow dogs? A lot of people seem to be moving there.) What really gets me about this one is that this isn’t an adult dog they’ve had for years, it’s a 12-week-old puppy. You didn’t know four weeks ago that you were going to move for your job? Or that you were going to apply for jobs in other states and it was a bad time to bring a new puppy into the house?

12 week old purebred boxer, shes playful, house trainned, good with kids and other animals, a rehoming fee will apply but willing to be flexable to a good home, we hate to see her go, but were relocating due to my job and unfortunately cant take her with us.  she comes with food, food bowl, leash and two toys

What are some examples you’ve seen of throw-away pet ownership?

More importantly, what can be done to keep people from viewing animals as being throw-away commodities like the latest tech junk or kitchen gadget? Obviously, the animal liberation nuts like PeTA and HSUS who want to end all pet ownership are not the answer. But how do we change the way people view animals?

Posted in posts. 2 Comments »

Calming Signals & Resource Guarding

My readers already know that I don’t exactly have an “I absolutely love this” relationship with Cesar Millan‘s TV show, “Dog Whisperer“, or any of the other television dog training shows, for that matter.

I think most programs and books on dog training do give us some worthwhile information. Sometimes this comes in the form of a method or approach that is thinking outside the box or gets us moving in the right direction when we’re stuck working on a particular issue or item or with a particular dog. Sometimes it comes in the form of things to add to the list we’d never, ever do to any dog we’re training. Sometimes it’s a little snippet here and there that’s useful, sometimes a lot. Often, it’s a lot of stuff that needs to go into the garbage and certainly should come with a “don’t try this at home” disclaimer.

The problem is that many dog owners and many dog trainers really don’t have the experience to pick out the good and leave the bad, or tell one from the other, which, I think, is what accounts for the popularity of Cesar’s TV show. Many people watch his show and say, “Wow, this guy really knows dogs and knows how to get them to do what he wants. It’s amazing how he fixed that dog.” Believe it or not, that’s exactly how his show looks to many dog owners who then go out and try those methods (even though Cesar’s show does have a disclaimer) on their own dogs.

The thing people need to realize, first and foremost, is that what they see is not what is actually happening. Like any reality television show, Cesar’s show is highly edited. You see what the editors want you to see – like a dog getting fixed in a short period of time and being perfectly well-behaved on Cesar’s return visit. What you don’t see is that this dog’s owner just went running with his dog for an hour, completely tiring him out, before that return visit segment was filmed. A tired dog is pretty much always a good dog. And you hardly ever hear about the ongoing, lengthy, daily commitment these owners have to make in order to keep their dog “fixed”.

The other thing people need to realize is that Cesar Millan honestly knows very little about canine body language. He’s frequently talking about dogs being “calm submissive” when in reality that dog is giving him just about every calming signal that is in its repertoire – and dogs have many of these calming signals, meant to appease in a situation that is uncomfortable, frightening, threatening to the dog.

There are many good publications on canine calming signals and canine body language available for those wanting to learn more about what their dogs are really saying. A good place to start is Turid Rugaas’ article, “Calming Signals – The Art of Survival” or her book, “On Talking Terms with Dogs: Calming Signals.” Another good book is Brenda Aloff’s “Canine Body Language: A Photographic Guide,” which shows photos of common behaviors and helps you learn more about what they mean in those contexts, helping you learn more about canine body language in general and reading it correctly. If you’re more visually oriented, I recommend the video “The Language of Dogs” by Sarah Kaljnas.

Let’s look at some of these body language “stress signals” in this video.

As you can see from the clip, my cat Ratchet is trying to interact with Ronja, my Belgian Malinois. Ronja isn’t quite as interested in this interaction as he is and is giving a lot of signals that communicate her discomfort.

At 11 seconds, you can see her quick tongue flick and “whale eye”, as well as her looking toward me (her handler) to come and take her out of this uncomfortable situation. At 35 seconds, she is beginning to remove her paws from the situation in hopes that Ratchet will leave her alone. A look back to me at 41 seconds, followed by another quick tongue flick at 51 seconds. As Ratchet begins to rub on her face at 1 minute, she turns her face away to avoid him and again licks her lips.

Now, Ronja is used to being around cats and doesn’t mind them as long as they leave her alone. She doesn’t seek interactions with them and takes it well when they chose to interact with her, as seen in this video, but she’s clearly communicating that this is an uncomfortable situation for her and that she’d prefer it if Ratchet just left her alone.

Now let’s watch the following video from Cesar Millan’s show, a clip titled “Showdown with Holly.”

When you’re watching this video, I’d like you to do so with the sound off and focusing only on the dog’s body language – not on Cesar’s body language or the sound. Then watch it again and focus on Cesar’s body language (and, if you must, the sound).

I see a dog here that is extremely uncomfortable with the interaction and is giving a whole host of calming / stress signals.

At 0 seconds in the video, as Cesar prepares to put the dog bowl down, we see her first tongue flick. She is positioned with ears back, shoulder turned toward Cesar with her body being in a slight c-shape, tail low. At 2 seconds, as Cesar puts down the bowl, she is turning her head to the side, lips pushed almost all the way forward, with a low tail wag, and then looks up at Cesar and squints. This is a dog who is uncomfortable, doesn’t like the interaction, and finds Cesar threatening.

Holly continues to turn her head sideways and squint her eyes at Cesar, giving him quick flicks of the ears. As she carefully begins to eat, Cesar leans forward (which is an intimidating gesture to this already uncomfortable dog), and Holly tenses and stiffens at 16 seconds. Stiffening or freezing is often a last way for a dog to communicate “this is really, really uncomfortable” and they may go from there into a fight or flight mode – either run away or, if they have no ability to, chose to fight. Cesar keeps getting closer, so Holly chooses to act defensively. However, look at her body posture at 18 seconds – she is growling and trying to grab the last of the kibble, but her body is leaning away from Cesar, tail tucked, hackles raised.

A lot of people automatically assume that raised hackles equal aggression, but they can mean many things. Many dogs hackle up when they’re aroused, which can be from plain excitement or from the uncertainty of greeting an unfamiliar dog, for example. It can also be from fear and yes, aggression. That’s why it’s important we look at the whole dog, not just the hackles before we jump to conclusions. Look at Holly at 21 seconds. She’s backed up and then lunged forward at Cesar again when he kept coming, but look at her posture. She’s leaning away, her body sideways to his, her tail tucked.

26 seconds gives us a side-by-side of Cesar and Holly’s face. Look closely at her face. Tongue flick after tongue flick, squinty eyes, flicking ears, stiff body. Holly is communicating that she has nowhere to go and is frightened. She’s also communicating that she doesn’t want to bite him – if she were an aggressive dog, rather than a dog on the defensive, she would have bitten him already – but she is letting him know that if he keeps pushing her and she has no place to get away from him, she will bite to defend herself. At 49 seconds, Holly lays down. Cesar hasn’t moved and she’s letting him know she’s okay with this if he leaves her alone and doesn’t keep pushing toward her.

As Cesar begins to talk, Holly is looking around herself, continuing with the largest signals of tongue flicks, ear flicks, and eye squinting. Contrary to what Cesar says at 1:10, Holly isn’t relaxed, and when Cesar pushes into her space, first with his hand and then with his whole body, she goes into defense mode and bites him.

When Cesar at 1:23 says, “I didn’t see that coming!” I have to wonder whether he suffers from some kind of sight impairment, or whether he really does not understand canine body language. Holly has given him nearly a minute and a half of signals that communicated distrust, discomfort, fear, defense, and a potential that she will bite if she felt cornered. The only way Holly could have been any more clear would have been to hold up a sign, “Get away from me or I will bite.”

That all said, Holly’s behavior over the food is called “resource guarding” – meaning she is protective of a resource, in this case her food, and uncomfortable with anyone approaching her while she’s eating. It’s not uncommon for dogs to be defensive over being approached when they’re eating or drinking – after all, they’re in a vulnerable position with their heads down – but resource guarding is more than that. It’s a fear that the person (or other animal) who is approaching is going to take their resource away. An excellent resource (no pun intended) on resource guarding is “Mine! A Practical Guide to Resource Guarding in Dogs” by Jean Donaldson for those wanting to learn more about this particular behavior and how to address it.

Now let’s see another television trainer, Victoria Stillwell, address resource guarding behavior. (Again, just to reiterate, I don’t agree with everything Victoria advocates or says on her show, either – this isn’t a Cesar vs. Victoria debate. However, these two videos do well illustrate working with a resource guarding, unsure, uncomfortable dog and the contrast in methods.)

In Victoria’s video, a dog named Mr. Black is being given a bowl of kibble and then approached while eating by his owners so Victoria can observe his behavior. As his owner approaches him, he growls and gives stress signals. At 25 seconds we see the “whale eye”. His body is stiff and turned sideways from the owners. He actually moves away from being touched. At 52 seconds, the dog’s owner has moved to the side of the bowl the dog moved to in order to get away from the people, and as he tries to approach the dog from that side, the dog urinates. This is a behavior called submissive urination and yes, it’s another type of calming signal in dog/dog and dog/human interactions.

As you continue on with the video, you can see the difference in Victoria’s approach, which is dog-friendly, and Cesar’s approach, which is, for lack of a better term, dog-aggressive. While Cesar pushes and bullies the uncomfortable, unsure dog into biting him, Victoria begins teaching her dog’s owners to teach the dog that he doesn’t need to feel uncomfortable about being approached while eating because good things happen when he is being approached while he’s at the food bowl. (I kinda wish Victoria’s video continued longer than it does, but she shows how to get started on making a dog that is resource guarding comfortable about being approached.)

Which dog do you think will be trained out of their behavior and happy to be approached by people? The dog Cesar worked with or the dog Victoria worked with (providing that either set of owners follow through on either method)? My guess would be that it would be the dog Victoria works with – who’ll not only be comfortable being approached, but will also go through a lot less stress in training in the process.

Now check out this video of dog/dog interactions by trainer Michael Burkey, which breaks down the behaviors of the two dogs, both the positive behaviors of the Rottweiler and the warning signals given by the Belgian Malinois, to reinforce the importance of looking for and reading canine body language when interacting with dogs and when dogs interact with each other.

Posted in posts. 1 Comment »